J Crew: Schoolboy Blazer in Tipped Linen, Schoolboy Blazer in Linen

Two of the new arrivals I could not decide on were the Schoolboy Blazer in Tipped Linen and the Schoolboy Blazer in Linen in Tornado Grey. With the Cardholder promo I ordered both to see which one I liked the best.

Unfortunately, they arrived today and I like them BOTH! I decided, after seeing the Linen in Grey that I needed a Grey Blazer for Spring/Summer. I ordered the Navy in the Tipped Linen in my size, 10 Petite. I chose the Navy because it looked like a bright gray as opposed to Blue. The sizing is perfect and now that I know how blazers should fit me based on that size I am a little picky.

I love that the Ruffled Rhinestone Shirt looks so good as a layering piece when I review blazers.

The white contrasts very well against the crosshatch. The blazer is lined in an Acetate/Poly stripe. The sleeves do have the striped lining and not a solid color. The buttons are lightweight and not like the Lexington buttons of yore but we all know that nothing compares to the Lexi. Now I think I might want the white one too. Although I’m seeing the lining show through the sleeves in the online pics. Not sure if I like that or not.

The Schoolboy Blazer in Linen in the Tornado Grey color looks true to the online images. When I took it out of the packaging I thought “meh, maybe not”, but then I put it on. I think it’s the Ruffled Rhinestone Shirt that sold me. 

Love how the ruffle it peeking just above the collar.

This is completely solid grey with no tipping on the outside anywhere. I don’t really care for the brown buttons too much. I think another color like Navy or White would have been nice. There’s an inside pocket. The lining is 100% cotton. The body lining is grey but the sleeve lining is striped. Love that!

Side-by-side…will they be friends in my closet or will I send one away?

Something that struct me as odd was that there is felt under the collar on the Linen Blazer. I think the same lining as the sleeves would have been a nice little touch instead. The Tipped Linen Blazer doesn’t have anything under the collar but the collar is tipped.

The Linen Blazer is a little heavier in weight than the Tipped Linen Blazer. It also feels a little rougher/sturdier/thicker. Not sure which but the Tipped Linen Blazer does feel thinner to the touch.

So my dilemma is do I keep both or return one? Which one if I do? I don’t find anything wrong with the Tipped Linen Blazer. I do have the Collection Classic Schoolboy Blazer in Tipped Linen from last Spring but that’s a darker Navy than this one. And I don’t have any other Springtime blazers. And the Grey is really nice and not something I think I could find elsewhere. I’ll figure it out, of course. 
 

Have a Great Evening!

11 Comments

  1. March 5, 2014 / 11:24 pm

    To me, the tipped linen is the standout for sure!

  2. March 5, 2014 / 11:39 pm

    I like the tipped linen. Ive been eyeing that one online but hesitated because i really dont need anymore blazers. After seeing yours, i may reconsider. Youre so right about the blouse; it really makes the blazer stand out, especially the ruffle peeking out from the collar, i really like that.

  3. March 5, 2014 / 11:44 pm

    I absolutely love the tipped one!

  4. March 6, 2014 / 12:32 am

    The tipped linen is soooo cute! Fits you really well and is very stylish!

  5. March 6, 2014 / 2:54 am

    The Tipped Linen is very flattering on you. The contrast trim has a lot of definition. You're right that the navy does look like a bright gray, and you can definitely see that when they are side by side. For some reason it also looks like it has more shape and is less boxy. It really looks good on you!

  6. March 6, 2014 / 8:57 am

    I love the tipped. The other one is plain. I kwym about grey blazer, but they might make a factory version for cheaper. I've come around to them a little more now that I found one that fit. The buttons on this one are meh. Something about it isn't perfect. Hold out.

  7. March 6, 2014 / 12:57 pm

    Definitely the Tipped Linen! So much more flattering on you!

  8. March 6, 2014 / 3:08 pm

    The plain gray may be more versatile but my vote is for the tipped one. Love it on you. It would look cute with white jeans and a striped tee or tank.

  9. March 6, 2014 / 7:50 pm

    I love the Tipped Linen Blazer! And, I love how you styled it!!!

  10. March 6, 2014 / 11:38 pm

    An overwhelming agreement of the Tipped Linen! Thanks everyone. After re-reading my post I found my cons of the solid Linen Blazer and it will be returned. Thanks for the input!